RUBIN, MICHAEL STEVEN; PHD
UNIVERSITY OF PENNSYLVANIA, 1986
BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION, MANAGEMENT (0454)
Statement of the Problem. Current theories of development do not adequately
address the mediating
role of human agency in transforming social systems. In large part this results
from the lack of a temporal
construct which links intermediate actions to longer term developmental ends.
The thesis proposes an
alternative temporal framework, which is then evaluated and elaborated through
an examination of
development projects. Procedure and Methods. The research was organized through
a four-part
procedure. First, active participation in the analysis of six large scale development
projects led to the
formulation of a number of propositions about the temporal structure and organization
of these efforts
and their relationship to the wider social system and its further development.
Second, a temporal
framework was developed to account for the observed patterns. An extensive literature
search on
theories of mediation and time was conducted to assess the relevance of the
framework. Third, the
projects were organized into formal case narratives through the use of extensive
project ethnographies
and analyses of the divergence between expectations and actual events in the
course of the project
engagements. Within-case analyses and Cross-case comparisons were employed in
constructing and
assessing the project settings. Finally, the episodic framework was employed
to provide an explanatory
account of transitions, modifications, conflicts and outcomes over the course
of the project
engagements. Results. First, the episodic framework was shown to provide an
enhanced account of the
organization and structuration of the development project. Second, a set of
synthetic constructs was
introduced to relate the project organization to the wider social system and
its longer term development
objectives. Finally, the problem of temporal inconsistency was revealed as a
critical impediment to the
adoption and implementation of development projects. Conclusions. Through a
discursive appreciation
of the episodic structure of the development project, these initiatives may
be better designed, managed,
and more appropriately positioned within the social system. The thesis contributes
to an understanding
of the mediation of development by providing a temporal construct which links
intermediate actions to
longer term developmental ends.
Social
Systems Simulation Group
P.O. Box 6904 San Diego, CA 92166-0904 Roland Werner, Principal Phone/FAX (619) 660-1603 |