This study investigated the influence of social networks on the leadership and
professional military
development of cadets. It was proposed that leadership development is a social
process involving the
growth of individuals as they move in a given direction toward a specified goal.
At an institution such as
the United States Air Force Academy, the goal is the training and development
of potential Air Force
leaders. This training takes place in an inherently social environment, yet
studies on the relationship
between social influences and leadership development are virtually non-existent.
Using a longitudinal
design over an academic year (August 1997 to May 1998), the study examined the
differences in the
composition of cadet social groups and their influence on leadership development
in two cadet
squadrons. Cadet peer groups, identified using Social Cognitive Map procedures
(Cairns,
Gariépy, & Kinderman, 1990), were influential and stable
components of the cadet
squadron social ecology. Cadets nominated as “being a good leader”
by their peers were
not necessarily the same cadets holding positions of formal leadership. These
“informal
leaders” performed better on academic and military performance measures
than other cadets in
the squadron, were more respected than other cadets in the squadron, and were
more central in the
squadron social network. An exploratory measurement model of leadership suggested
that leadership is
best measured by both the formal position one holds, as well as, ratings of
leadership effectiveness and
respect obtained from other cadets in the squadron. Hostile aggression was also
related to the degree of
respect received from other squadron members and to measures of informal leadership.
Cadets who had
high ratings of hostile aggression were less likely to receive peer nominations
for being one of the
“most respected cadets” in the squadron. They were also
less likely to be considered a
leader in the squadron. Combined, the results from this study suggest that social
relationships within a
cadet squadron provide a rich and important context for leadership training.
The characteristics of cadet
social groups have the potential to influence leadership development trajectories.
Several suggestions
are provided to aid commanders in applying these findings.
Social
Systems Simulation Group
P.O. Box 6904 San Diego, CA 92166-0904 Roland Werner, Principal Phone/FAX (619) 660-1603 |