Gideon, Barbara Hand; EdD
TEXAS A&M UNIVERSITY, 2000
EDUCATION, ADMINISTRATION (0514); EDUCATION, SECONDARY (0533)
This investigation explores the conditions that foster the adoption of an innovation
in schools as well as
those conditions that serve as barriers to change. Educational reform is a popular
topic in our society.
Reform initiatives are plentiful; however, few result in improved student achievement.
The purpose of
this study is to examine the emergence of multiple leadership roles that emerge
and the barriers to
leadership as one urban high school extended a successful innovation to a wider
population at the
school. This study documents renewal at Crockett High School, a large urban
high school in Austin,
Texas. A team of teachers guided the implementation of the innovations and assisted
the researcher.
The research team utilized the framework established by Argyris and Schön
(1974, 1996) to
analyze, categorize and refine the practices implemented at our school. The
research questions
addressed are: (1) How is the existence of Model I theories-in-use
(Argyris & Schön
1974) evident in the interpersonal relationships and organizational learning
of Crockett High School; and
(2) How is the existence of Model II theories-in-use (Argyris &
Schön 1974) evident in
the interpersonal relationships and organizational learning of Crockett High
School? The Argyris and
Schön (1974, 1996) constructs provided the research team with a common
vocabulary, a
framework for discussion and guided collective thought processes. In this way,
the members of the
research team were able to recognize self-sealing thought patterns and redirect
themselves to utilize all
valid data, resulting in double-loop learning. As we used this spiral process,
our organizational learning
and effectiveness increased, allowing us to monitor and adjust the innovations
and to create conditions
conducive to school renewal. This study adds to the body of knowledge, regarding
the multiple roles of
leadership that facilitate the process of school renewal and the subtle shifts
in human dynamics and the
environment, which move a promising practice from being simply an innovation
in isolation to being part
of the fabric of the school culture.
Social
Systems Simulation Group
P.O. Box 6904 San Diego, CA 92166-0904 Roland Werner, Principal Phone/FAX (619) 660-1603 |